CMI Tribute

The CMI Tribute is designed to honour members of the Charlotte Mason community who have made significant contributions to promoting Charlotte Mason’s ideas for education.

Almost a century after her death, Charlotte Mason’s design for education continues to stir the imagination and practice of parents and teachers and impact the lives and education of thousands of children. Without the contributions of some key individuals, however, it may well be that Charlotte Mason’s influence would not be felt across the world in our times. The CMI Tribute is designed to recognize such individuals.

2021 Honouree

Carroll Smith


Over the past two decades, Dr. Carroll Smith has shaped the Charlotte Mason movement in countless ways.

He completed his doctoral studies on Charlotte Mason with a dissertation titled Charlotte Mason: An Introductory Analysis of Her Educational Theories and Practices and has since added numerous areas of related study to his knowledge, insight, and critique of Mason’s design for education.

He founded the Charlotte Mason Institute (formally ChildLight USA) and, beginning in 2005, he and his wife Andra, began organizing and hosting the Charlotte Mason Institute Annual Conference, now in its 17th year, creating a relational space for deep and honest conversations around Mason’s ideas. Thousands of educators (over 2000 have attendees over the years)—home educators, classroom teachers, and school administrators—have been influenced by the relationships and content they explored and shared at the CMI conferences. At these conference, Dr. Smith has offered plenaries, workshops, and practice sessions on a wide variety of topics such as narration, Mason in the 21st century, dualism in education, living books, and more.

He was also granted research support through the Canadian government from the Humanities and Social Science Research Council of Canada, towards a two year project Charlotte Mason Collection Digitization at Armitt Museum 2009-2011 now housed at Redeemer University.

He was appointed by CMI and the University of Cumbria as a Visiting Research Fellow in Charlotte Mason Studies from 2020 to 2025. And he is serving as the 2021 Scholar-in-Residence in Charlotte Mason Studies at the University of Cumbria where he is working on a project analyzing the letters of Charlotte Mason. During his residency and the following eighteen months he plans to complete a monograph on the letters of Mason to Henrietta Franklin and a book of Mason’s letters, completed in collaboration with previous CMI Tribute recipient, Dr. John Thorley, former principal of the Charlotte Mason College. He hopes these projects will enhance understanding about women in leadership; about Mason’s biography and the influence of relationships on her educational thought; and about the applicability of Mason’s design for education today.

Throughout all his efforts, Dr. Smith has worked tirelessly for the children’s sake and for the sake of all teachers and students in every setting. He is generous with his time, his energy, his devotion to spreading Mason’s life-changing ideas—the fruit of which will be seen in the decades and perhaps even centuries to come.


Dr. Carroll Smith was introduced to Charlotte Mason many years ago through Mason’s book An Essay Towards a Philosophy of Education.  From there the seeds of ideas given by Mason in her various books have slowly taken hold and have grown year by year as Carroll worked as a middle school teacher, a principal and a college professor in both public settings and Mason-inspired schools.  He founded the educational nonprofit, The Charlotte Mason Institute, to promote the educational philosophy of Charlotte Mason and cherishes the relationships that have gown over the years through a collective camaraderie with people interested in seeing education from a very different paradigm. He enjoys reading, gardening and discussing ideas with friends.  He and his wife, Andra live in Roanoke, VA, and also enjoy visiting their granddaughter, Lily, in the UK.

2019 Honouree

Karen Andreola


Like so many of us, Karen Andreola learned about Charlotte Mason through Susan Schaeffer Macaulay’s book For the Children’s Sake.  Karen and Dean Andreola gave the fuel to the movement started by Macaulay’s book by publishing Mason’s six volumes in 1988 called the Original Homeschooling Series.  Her “pink” books are familiar to so many people in the Mason movement.  The republication of these books was a major contribution to the Mason movement.  Karen further gave fuel to the movement by publishing her very practical interpretation of Mason’s methods in her perennial bestseller A Charlotte Mason Companion: Personal Reflections on The Gentle Art of Learning™. She and Dean created The Gentle Art of Learning™ as their company brand. It represents their personal interpretation and application of the Charlotte Mason method. They home educated their three children from kindergarten through grade12. Karen republished and edited some of the Parents’ Review from 1991 to 1996. Because of its timeless articles and advertisement-free pages, interest in Parents’ Review continues.  These efforts on the part of Karen Andreola contributed significantly to the continuation of Charlotte Mason’s ideas to the present day.


Karen Andreola has dedicated her life to encouraging and teaching mothers how to teach and raise their own children. Ever since a child, Karen’s dream was to be a wife, mother, and homemaker and the philosophy and work of Charlotte Mason became a substantial part of that dream, both in her work home educating her children and in her work as a speaker and writer trying to make Mason’s methods approachable and relevant to modern-day homeschool moms.

When Karen was a mother of young children, her husband’s work had taken them to live in London where Karen began reading For the Children’s Sake by Susan Schaeffer Macaulay. She found the gentle authority and enormous practicality of Mason’s words so compelling that an extensive search for more of Mason’s books began–a search that took husband Dean to Ambleside to the campus of the Charlotte Mason College and to Dr. John Thorley who loaned the Andreolas a complete set of Mason’s volumes.

Home to the USA came the Adreolas in 1987 with this set and within a few years they saw to it that all six of Mason’s volumes were republished as The Original Homeschooling Series. For two decades the Andreolas published Mason’s volumes, making Mason accessible to so many of us in the Mason community before the wide availability of the internet.

With her quiet resoluteness, Karen plunged into Mason’s works, continually exploring new ways to practically implement Mason’s methods. A decade of watching his wife homeschool their children and teach homeschool co-op classes gave Dean the subtitle for Karen’s first book A Charlotte Mason Companion: Personal Reflections on The Gentle Art of Learning.  Dean reflects: “Karen may well have been one of the very first homeschool moms reading, experimenting, and exploring new ways to “bring Charlotte Mason home.”

Subsequent years brought further speaking and writing with Karen using whatever vehicle of communication the Lord provided: author, magazine editor, featured columnist, keynote speaker, first CM home-study group leader, blogger, and homeschool product reviewer (14 years for Christian Book Distributors). Even though health issues limit Karen’s public speaking, she uses writing to continue her life’s work of encouraging young mothers. Each year this grandmother still answers hundreds of letters and emails from overworked or discouraged mothers.  In her latest book (which took eight years to write) Mother Culture:  For a Happy Homeschool, Karen hopes to capture the noble ideals and methods of Mason to inspire moms with creative ways to cheer up their homeschools and avoid burnout.

2018 Honouree

Deani Van Pelt, PhD


Dr. Deani Van Pelt first attended the Charlotte Mason Institute Conference in 2005. Since then, Dr. Van Pelt has tenaciously supported the work of the Institute as well as the general Mason community.

In 2007 Dr. Van Pelt contacted Dr. Carroll Smith (Gardner-Webb University) concerning writing a grant to obtain funds for a Mason education project. With support from Dr. Smith and Dr. Jack Beckman (Covenant College), Dr. Van Pelt wrote a grant proposal to the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada. Upon receiving the grant in 2008, Dr. Van Pelt convened a group in Ambleside, UK to develop plans for a larger project. That group included Drs. Smith and Beckman, Lisa Cadora (CMI Board Chair), Dr. Jennifer Spencer (then a graduate student of Dr. Smith’s), and Dr. John Thorley (last principal of the Charlotte Mason College). From those meetings came the idea to digitize the Charlotte Mason Archive at the Armitt Museum, Gallery and Library.

Dr. Van Pelt prepared an additional SSHRC grant application in 2010 and its successful award enabled her to lead a number of Mason scholars and practitioners to the Armitt to digitize much of the collection. The team included Dr. Beckman, Dr. Spencer, Gladys Schaefer (CMI Board Member), Dr. John Thorley, and Marlene Power (Redeemer University College). Without Dr. Van Pelt’s work and dedication, the Charlotte Mason Digital Collection (CMDC) would not exist.

The receipt of several additional internal grants from Redeemer University College combined with the dedicated work of Marlene Power and many students hours, the CMDC was established at Redeemer University College in Ancaster, Canada. The significance of this project may be best illustrated by the fact that the CMDC has been viewed over 66,000 times since it was recently added to the Internet Archive in October of 2016. In the past year, there have been well over 5,000 additional views of the CMDC directly through the original website at Redeemer College.

In establishing the CMDC, Dr. Van Pelt has facilitated access to the Charlotte Mason archive for thousands of individuals from across the globe interested in the study and application of Mason’s educational work and ideas. Prior to the digital collection, travel to the north of England was needed to peruse the archive. Her vision, grant writing and leadership have enabled widespread access to the archive and contributed to the expansion in the study of Mason’s approach to education.

Dr. Van Pelt’s work on the CMDC alone meets the CMI tribute criterion, which is to recognize key individuals who have brought the work of Charlotte Mason into the 21st century so that it can benefit many children. But Dr. Van Pelt’s work goes further. Her master’s thesis Charlotte Mason’s Design for Education (2001) was one of the first graduate theses in Canada prepared on Mason’s educational philosophy. In collaboration with her daughter, Meghan Van Pelt, she contributed a chapter, L’Umile Pianta, to the first volume of the Institute’s Essays on the Life and Work of Charlotte Mason. She has presented multiple plenaries and workshop sessions at the CMI conferences throughout the past ten years. Most recently, she helped to organize and lead the 2018 English Lake District Retreat at St. Mary’s Church in Ambleside, England.

Dr. Van Pelt has become an invaluable spokesperson for Charlotte Mason’s design for education as she represents Mason’s ideas broadly via video, podcasts, articles, and lectures. The CMI board is proud to honor the work of someone so dedicated to the work and ideas of Charlotte Mason and we look forward to many more years of working with Dr. Van Pelt as she continues to study and share Charlotte Mason’s ideas in Canada and beyond.


Deani Van Pelt, PhD, currently the president of a new independent school association in Ontario, Canada, is a former Associate Professor of Education and Director of Teacher Education at Redeemer University College and author of many studies in education policy for the think tanks, Fraser Institute and Cardus. Together with an international team, in 2008, Deani was awarded a grant from the Social Sciences and Humanities Research Council of Canada to digitize the documents in the Charlotte Mason Collection held at the Armitt Museum in Ambleside, UK. The results of the digitization project have meant access to Mason’s (previously almost inaccessible) works by a new generation of scholars and practitioners. Over the last decade, access to the collection through Internet Archive and the Redeemer University College Library website has stimulated increasingly widespread research and application of Mason’s ideas for education. Deani is passionate about excellent educational design and believes we have much to learn from Charlotte Mason for education in our times. She is thankful for the role the Charlotte Mason Institute has played in building and promoting the digital collection.

© 2018 Deani Van Pelt

2017 Honourees

Margaret A. Coombs, MPhil


In her book, Charlotte Mason: Hidden Heritage and Educational Influence (The Lutterworth Press, 2015), Margaret Coombs rediscovers for a new generation the previously unknown biography and influences of Charlotte Mason. Coombs’ years of meticulous research and lively style illuminate hitherto unknown details of Mason’s story and origins of her ideas, and undoubtedly will benefit researchers and practitioners for decades to come.


Margaret and her husband, Martin, a retired Anglican Vicar, live in multi-cultural, multi-faith, East Oxford and attend St Mary & St John Church. Her son, Daniel, is an artist and art lecturer and her daughter, Anna, is artistic director and founder of an innovatory African and African Caribbean theatre company, serving south west England.

Margaret studied classics at school and sociology at London University. Joining the London Samaritans instilled in her the importance of respecting the humanity of all people, regardless of their problems. This guided her subsequent mental health work. Qualifying as a psychiatric social worker at the LSE brought a wonderfully varied mental health career in England and overseas. She has also lectured, engaged in research projects and chaired proactive committees. Highlights include action-research as a community care rights adviser, learning from Oxford Survivors and sharing patients’ concerns, as a mental health act commissioner. Retirement in 2008 and meeting with transatlantic Charlotte Mason enthusiasts inspired her to develop her 1984 post-graduate thesis on Education for Parenthood by the PNEU into her new biography, Charlotte Mason Hidden Heritage and Educational Influence, Lutterworth, 2015.

© 2017 by Margaret Coombs

Susan Schaeffer Macaulay, MA


Susan Schaeffer Macaulay’s book, For the Children’s Sake: Foundations of Education for Home and School (Crossway Books, 1984), recovered Charlotte Mason’s ideas from history and made them attractive to a new generation of parents and teachers. Without her inspiring, sensitive, and insightfully articulated work the international resurgence of interest in Charlotte Mason, almost surely, would not have occurred in the last three decades.


Born in Grove City, Pennsylvania in 1941 to parents Francis and Edith Schaeffer, Susan lived in Europe with her missionary parents following World War II encouraging, befriending and teaching on the reliability of the Bible. Although her own elementary school education was dull, Susan’s home life and family conversations resonated with touches of a Charlotte Mason atmosphere. Books, including books of the Bible, were read in full sequence, and narrated back to one another. Sundays included the children narrating the sermons which her father had preached, careful as he was to make “the feeding station low enough for the lambs”. Both parents frequently read aloud in the home and the cadence of their voices sharing all manner of poetry and prose still resonates in Susan’s memory. Scouting, frequent walks in mountain and forest, as well as trips to art galleries and museums marked Susan’s childhood. Although illness kept Susan from attending formal secondary school, the packages from Calvert and the daily lessons filled her with joy and created a lifelong enthusiasm for learning. She studied occupational therapy at Oxford, England, felt the Lord’s leading in her meeting Ranald Macaulay while there, and they married in 1961. Together they then served with her parents at L’Abri in Switzerland (1961 -1964) where their first daughter was born, then in London establishing a L’Abri home there (1964-1971) and their second and third daughters were born, and then establishing a residential L’Abri 60 miles south of London (1971-1996). In the early years there their son was born, and two young children whose parents had died also joined their family. These years were full and always marked by conversation, cooking, meals, and daily life shared with young people, lectures being given, conferences organized, and books being written, including: Something Beautiful from God (Crossway), How to be Your Own Selfish Pig (Summit Ministries), and For the Children’s Sake (Crossway). In 1996 Susan and Ranald settled in Cambridge to fruitful years of serving more locally, writing another book, For the Family’s Sake (Crossway), and attending to physical health and healing. With family now wide-spread, and separation not being easy, they “anticipate the great reunion ahead and the “Forever Family in a ‘Better Home’ (Hebrews 11)”.

© 2017 by Susan Schaeffer Macaulay

John Thorley, PhD


Dr. John Thorley’s selfless foresight in rescuing Mason’ archives as he retired as principal of the Charlotte Mason College, as he subsequently worked in organizing and cataloguing it, and then housed it at the Armitt Library and Museum in Ambleside, Cumbria, UK, almost single-handedly has made further research, study and application of Mason’s ideas possible in our times. Dr. Thorley’s ongoing encouragement and availability to scholars all over the world continues to impact how Mason’s ideas are understood today.


John came from the mining and industrial area of South Yorkshire. The secondary school where he went taught a broad curriculum including classical and modern languages, which became a life-long interest for him. He went to Durham University in the north of England, where he studied Greek and Latin. He then taught for ten years before taking posts in Cumbria, first as an Education Officer, then as a School Inspector, then as head of a large secondary and community school in Carlisle, and finally as Principal of Charlotte Mason College in Ambleside. In his last two years at Ambleside the College merged with Lancaster University to become the university’s Faculty of Education, of which John became Dean, while still remaining Principal of the College and Professor of Education.

Since retiring from his full-time post, John has catalogued the Charlotte Mason archive held in the Armitt Library on the College campus. He has also continued his interest in Latin and Greek by teaching Greek and Medieval Latin to post-graduates at Lancaster University and by teaching Greek History at the University of Cumbria. Until recently he taught every summer at an annual conference in Greece on Homeric Studies, run by a European Classical organisation, EUROCLASSICA, of which John was president in 1991-1995. John has published books on Athenian Democracy and Medieval Latin, and articles on Roman History, New Testament Greek, medieval Cumbria, and Charlotte Mason.

John attends his local Anglican church, he rings church bells in the traditional English style, he walks on the hills of Cumbria and elsewhere, and he retains an interest in education, though now mainly at a safe distance.

© 2017 John Thorley